Hosted by
Tereza Coraggio

Third Paradigm is an out-of-the-box thinktank on community sovereignty and regenerative economics.

We look at how to take back our cities, farmland and water; our money, production and trade; our media, education and culture, our religion and even our God.

We present a people's history of the Bible and a parent's view on how to raise giving kids in a taking world.

Search this Site
Keep updated every week with summaries of new radios shows, plus original writing posted on the site.

Subscribe to RSS Feed
3rd Paradigm is broadcast on:

Radio Free Brighton
Tu 2:30 pm, Th 5:30 pm (UK)
Tu 6:30 am, Th 9:30 am (PST)

Free Radio Santa Cruz
Listen Live Sun 1:30 PST

Upstart Radio online

Tereza has been interviewed on...

Talkabout with Kevin Spitzer, KZSC Santa Cruz

3rd Paradigm has been featured on these shows and stations:

Unwelcome Guests
by Robin Upton
on multiple stations

The Wringer
by Pete Bianco

WHCL Hamilton College

Global Notes
by Roger Barrett
CHLS Radio Lillooet

New World Notes
by Ken Dowst, WWUH
West Hartford, CT

3rd Paradigm has been viewed from:


Chatswood, NSW
Liverpool, NSW
Sydney, NSW
Brisbane, Queensland
Adelaide, S. Australia
Hurstbridge, Victoria
Melbourne, Victoria
Mildura, Victoria


Graz, Steiermark




Burssels, Hoofdstedelijk Gewest
Zoersel, Antwerpen


La Paz

Bosnia & Herzegovina

Bijeljina, Republica Srpska


Curitiba, Parana
Guaranta do Norte
Sao Paulo


Sofia, Grad Sofiya


Edmonton, Alberta
Red Deer, Alberta
Agassiz, BC
Burnaby, BC
Nelson, BC
Port Coquitlam, BC
Richmond, BC
Victoria, BC
Hubbart Point, Manitoba
Halifax, Nova Scotia
Stewiacke, Nova Scotia
Brampton, Ontario
Guelph, Ontario
Brantford, Ontario
Kingston, Ontario
Kitchener, Ontario
Longueuil, Ontario
Thornhill, Ontario
Toronto, Ontario
Waterloo, Ontario
Longueuil, Quebec
Montreal, Quebec


Santiago, Region Metropolitana


Nanjing, Jiangsu


Rijeka, Primorsko-Goranska


Ålborg, Nordjylland
Joure, Friesland
Nørre, Alslev Storstrom
Odense, Fyn
Tranbjerg, Arhus


Cairo, Al Qahirah
Alexandria, Al Iskandariyah


Martigues, Provence-Alpes-Cote d'Azur
Saint-Martin-d'heres, Rhone-Alpes


Gomaringen, Baden-Wurttemberg
Aachen, Nordrhein-Westfalen
Dusseldorf, Nordrhein-Westlfalen
Halle, Sachsen-Anhalt
Reitburg, Nordrhein-Westlfalen

Hong Kong

Central District


Bangalore, Karnataka
Haveri, Karnataka
Hyderabad, Andhra Pradesh
Madras, Tamal Nadu
Mumbai, Maharashtra
New Delhi


Bogor, Jawa Barat


Tehran, Esfahan




Tel Aviv


Modena, Emilia-Romagna


Nagoya, Aichi


Amman, Amman Governate


Vilnius, Vilniaus Apskritis




Segambut, Kuala Lumpur




Distrito Federal
Cancun, Quintana Roo
Playa del Carmen, Quintana Roo

Moldova, Republic of



Arnhem, Gelderland
Diemen, Noord Holland
Joure, Friesland
Lelystad, Flevoland
Tilburg, Noord-Brabant

New Zealand

Dobson, West Coast


Benin, Edo


Arendal, Aust-Agder
Mestervik, Troms


Rawalpindi, Punjab


Pueblo Nuevo, Chiriqui


Pisco, Ica


Cainta, Rizal
Diliman, Bulacan
Philippine, Benguet
Quezon City
Roosevelt, Masbate
Quezon, Nueva Ecija


Katowice, Slaskie


Algueirão, Lisboa
Atouguia Da Baleia, Leiria
Carnaxide, Lisboa
Guimarães, Braga
Sines, Setubal


Doha, Ad Dawhah



Saudi Arabia

Riyadh, Ar Riyad






Victoria, Beau Vallon



South Africa

Cape Town, Western Cape
Johannesburg, Gauteng
Roodepoort, Gauteng
Parow, Western Cape

South Korea

Seoul, Seoul-t'ukpyolsi


Barcelona, Catalonia
Salamanca, Castilla y Leon
Tarragona, Catalonia

Sri Lanka

Kandy, Central


Gothenburg, Vastra Gotaland
Storvreta, Uppsala Lan
Sundbyburg, Stockholms Lan


Biel, Bern
Lausanne, Vaud
Sarnen, Obwalden

Syrian Arab Republic

Damascus, Dimashq


Bangkok, Krung Thep




Kiev Kyyivs'ka Oblast'


Huddersfield, Kirklees
Larkhall, South Lanarkshire
Market Drayton, Shropshire
Surbiton, Surrey
Sutton Coldfield, West Midlands
Twickenham, Richmond upon Thames

United Arab Emirates





Cabudare, Lara
3rd Paradigm is grateful for:

Wikipedia Affiliate Button

Ironweed Film Club

Foreign Policy in Focus

Reality Sandwich

Charity Focus

Past Shows


Clash of the Continents: Climate Debt

December 20, 2009

3P-054 Show Information (includes MP3 download link)

Welcome to the 54th episode of Third Paradigm. Our title this week is Clash of the Continents: Climate Debt. We'll also post an interview we did with Barbara Ehrenreich on her recent book Bright-Sided: How the Relentless Promotion of Positive Thinking Has Undermined America. It may not seem obvious, but we believe there's an important relationship between her research and the discussions going on outside the Bela Center at the Copenhagen Climate Summit. In this frigid Danish beaker, a potent sociological cocktail is being swirled. Some of the volatile chemicals are mining and deforestation, economics and militarization, global inequity and entitlement. The brew frothed over when a secret memo was leaked between the US, the UK, and Denmark, to allow people who live in developed countries twice the carbon allotment of undeveloped countries.

The question arose in my mind – what's the discrepancy now between carbon output per capita in developed countries and undeveloped countries? Would twice the carbon allotment be an aggressive goal, or would it allow gas-guzzling nations to keep the pedal to the metal? I attempted to drill down on this number, pun intended. At first, I could only find charts that ordered countries by their overall carbon footprint. They made a big deal over how China has surpassed the US. But what does that mean, when you look at the population of China compared to the US? To look at carbon output without calculating it per person seemed like nonsense.

Once again, Wikipedia galloped to my rescue. My website now sports a handy Wikimedia button, in case you want to support their annual fundraiser, as I did this week. For me, they've made research into a treasure hunt where one clue leads to another. And I find secrets no expert would reveal. Viva la passionate amateurs!

There I found a link that listed countries by annual carbon emissions per capita. And the winner is... Qatar with a whopping 56 metric tons a year per person. That makes United Arab Emirates, Kuwait, and Bahrain seem almost girlish with their 30-ton figures. Next come Aruba, Trinidad and Tobago, Luxembourg and the Netherlands in the low to mid-twenties. What are they doing, smoking their emissions? Or is it because of the jets and cruise ships schlepping tourists around?

After these eight minuscule countries comes the US with 19 metric tons per. This 2007 rate is the same as in 1990 when the Wikipedia chart begins. But the DataBlog of the UK Guardian, with the subtitle "Facts are Sacred," has a post by Adam Vaughan that agrees that per capita statistics are the only way to go. By his data (view pdf), which goes back to 1950, the US spiked up to 22 in 1978, and has been declining ever since. Despite our government killing the electric car, blocking mass transit funding, and forcing an emissions-hogging military on us, it seems that we, the people, are trying. According to BusinessGreen and British analyst Maplecroft, Australia has now surpassed the US in per capita emissions at 20.5 and is not trying – at least not the government; I don't assume their people have any more control over their government than we do.

The US is followed closely by Canada, the Falkland Islands, Oman, and Saudi Arabia. Most developed countries hover around 10, but France, Malta, Portugal, and Hungary have dropped below 6. South Africa is neck-to-neck with Italy at 7, which surprised me. South Africa's emissions are certainly not from an Italian quality of life. Is it from oil production? China is 96th out of 210 countries with 4.6 tons per person. Adam Vaughan's chart shows that China's trajectory reached the world average of 4.2 in 2004. A note on Wikipedia points out that these statistics don't account for export manufacturing, which is a third of China's emissions, or for countries who avoid emissions by importing, no names mentioned but we know who we are.

Twice the 4.2 global average would be 8.4 tons, and twice that again would be 16.8. The US is at 19.8, or three tons more than four times the global average. If the 2050 goal for developed countries were 8.4 tons per capita, or twice the allotment for developing countries, it would require us to cut our emissions by 57% – which is more than the 40% goal called for by the climate summit. Most European countries would be already in this ballpark, with 8.4 as a workable goal. If "developing" countries set their goal at 4.2, China would need to make trade-offs between emissions for dirty manufacturing vs. quality of life. 43% of countries, or 91, are at less than half of average emissions, 2 tons or less. If the 25 countries over 8.4 were to cut their emissions by 2% per year, it would make a far bigger impact than paying money to impoverished nations. The US would need to drop by .4 tons per capita per year. The only developing country that would need to curb emissions would be South Africa. Does this have anything to do with their righteous indignation over the leaked memo?

But when we return, we're going to look at why this analysis doesn't tell the whole story either. We'll check out some other global statistics that indicate who really owes the climate debt and how we could get them to pay, guaranteeing that the money gets in the right hands. We'll also present an incentive plan for people in the US to cut their emissions, not by 40% or 57%, but by 80% by the year 2050. And it would start by making us honest. First, however, we're going to break for some poems about less complicated things. This is "Almost a Conversation" by Mary Oliver, and "The Seven of Pentacles" by Marge Piercy. The music is Alpha Yaya Diallo with Bambara Blues.

Almost a Conversation

I have not really, not yet, talked with otter
about his life.

He has so many teeth, he has trouble
with vowels.

Wherefore our understanding
is all body expression—

he swims like the sleekest fish,
he dives and exhales and lifts a trail of bubbles.
Little by little he trusts my eyes
and my curious body sitting on the shore.

Sometimes he comes close.
I admire his whiskers
and his dark fur which I would rather die than wear.

He has no words, still what he tells about his life
is clear.
He does not own a computer.
He imagines the river will last forever.
He does not envy the dry house I live in.
He does not wonder who or what it is that I worship.
He wonders, morning after morning, that the river
is so cold and fresh and alive, and still
I don't jump in.

~ Mary Oliver ~
From Evidence

* * * * * * * *

The Seven Of Pentacles

Under a sky the color of pea soup
she is looking at her work growing away there
actively, thickly like grapevines or pole beans
as things grow in the real world, slowly enough.
If you tend them properly, if you mulch, if you water,
if you provide birds that eat insects a home and winter food,
if the sun shines and you pick off caterpillars,
if the praying mantis comes and the ladybugs and the bees,
then the plants flourish, but at their own internal clock.

Connections are made slowly, sometimes they grow underground.
You cannot tell always by looking what is happening.
More than half the tree is spread out in the soil under your feet.
Penetrate quietly as the earthworm that blows no trumpet.
Fight persistently as the creeper that brings down the tree.
Spread like the squash plant that overruns the garden.
Gnaw in the dark and use the sun to make sugar.

Weave real connections, create real nodes, build real houses.
Live a life you can endure: Make love that is loving.
Keep tangling and interweaving and taking more in,
a thicket and bramble wilderness to the outside but to us
interconnected with rabbit runs and burrows and lairs.

Live as if you liked yourself, and it may happen:
reach out, keep reaching out, keep bringing in.
This is how we are going to live for a long time: not always,
for every gardener knows that after the digging, after the planting,
after the long season of tending and growth, the harvest comes.

~ Marge Piercy ~
From In Praise of Fertile Land, edited by Claudia Mauro
The music was Alpha Yaya Diallo with Bambara Blues. Thank you to Dan Robert of The Shortwave Report for sending it from his poetry and music show, Rhythm Running River. The poems were Almost a Conversation by Mary Oliver and The Seven of Pentacles by Marge Piercy. I want the life that they describe. Don't you? The time to talk to an otter, a thicket and bramble wilderness interconnected with rabbit runs and burrows and lairs. My 19.8 tons of emissions haven't done much for me lately. I crave simplicity and security, as others do, which is why fortunes can be made on quilting patterns, and why my daughter's friend is baking gingerbread houses for her 18th birthday.

But according to Evo Morales, Naomi Klein, Vendana Shiva, and Desmond Tutu – some of the people I most admire in the world - you and I are high-rolling capitalists who just plunked down billions to save our beloved banks. I'm certainly feeling wealthy since we did that. I went right out and bought a new gas-guzzling clothesline, since I wore out the old one trying not to use the dryer. In retribution for our decadent lifestyles, flaunting our cushy carbon emissions during our 2-hr commutes, we owe a climate debt. Tack it right on to the 13 trillion our credit card limit has been raised to. Of course, our credit's not good at certain establishments: healthcare, education, or social security. But I'm sure there's enough to pay off some African nations if there's oil greasing the skids.

But Evo, Naomi, Vendana, and Desmond, may I ask one little question…how will this help us reduce our carbon footprint? I don't mean to argue – I just need someone to explain the connection to me. Our average personal debt is already 15 months gross income, and the national debt was twice our net assets before the handouts, I mean bailouts. Should we be paying more in taxes, those who still have a job or a house, I mean? Should we have greater austerity in our social programs, if that's possible? Or should we just shoot ourselves, going out with one last big bang of carbon emissions?

Debt and taxes are the two biggest threats to sovereignty, which effects both developed and developing countries. Wikipedia has another handy reference - the list of external debt per capita. This includes both public and private or corporate debt owed to anyone outside the country. Did you know that every lad and lassie born in Ireland owes $450,000, and each Iceland papoose $360 grand? They're both at 1000% of GDP. Brit babes and Swiss maids owe half this, with $175k each. Belgian whelps are close behind at $125k. The infants of Norway, Denmark, Austria, and Hong Kong all owe a cool $100k. Swedish, French, and German toddlers are toting a heavier load in their diapers than the US, although this was back in June when our debt was mere $42,000 each and 95% of GDP. But Monaco takes the debt cake with $540,000 per and 1800% of GDP. At the opposite end of the spectrum, China owes less than $300 per person and 5% of GDP.

At least 198 countries owe from millions to billions to trillions. According to economist Susan George, the global south pays the north $200 billion a year. That could buy a lot of solar ovens. To whom is the money owed? In my research on Third World debt, I remember learning that it was related to the price of oil. When oil went up, the sheiks and robber barons made more money than they could find takers for. And so they created a third world money market with white elephant projects – foisting development loans on countries for things they didn't need or want.

In Liberia, after they'd agreed to a land concession for a rubber plantation, Firestone forced them to accept a loan. They refused, on the grounds that they didn't need it and it was bad business to owe money to a leaseholder. Firestone threatened US military intervention if they didn't take it, which wasn't an idle threat. And so take it they did. Loans from other sources to Charles Taylor's regime paid for the weapons and drugs that made children into killers. Altogether, Liberia ended up with 1.2 billion of debt for one of the 15 poorest countries on the planet. Decades later, through international pressure and activism, they won a buy-out of the debt for 3 cents on the dollar.

But two debtors held out, waited for the dust to settle, and then sued in British court. Called vulture funds, these give vultures a bad name by preying on the living. They buy up loans to countries eligible for absolution. After the loans are forgiven, they swoop in and declare that their loans weren't settled. For 6 million in loans, the British court awarded a 20 million settlement. This is equal to their whole education budget and 1.5X their health budget. Jubilee USA has gotten the Stop Vulture Funds Act into the Senate. You can help get it passed by sending a message to your Congress member from Jubilee's website.

Global Witness published a 2006 report called Heavy Mittal, (view pdf) which looked at Mittal Steel's exploitation of Liberia. Like Firestone, it's a revealing case study of the global dominance of transnational corporations. Of the 100 largest economies in the world, 51 are corporations while only 49 are countries. While people don't have a say in their country's debt, and may not have been born yet when it was acquired, they're still held liable for it. Executives and Board members of a corporation, however, can't be sued for their company's debt. Once they've transferred the profits into private pockets, the corporation can declare bankruptcy and dissolve. But even that may not be necessary. In a practice called liability-sheltering, a parent company can allows their subsidiary to go bankrupt without affecting them, skipping town and skipping country on their creditors, so to speak.

David Bayer in Peru sent me an article called Beware the Psychopath, My Son by Clinton Callahan. Extracted from two articles: Twilight of the Psychopaths, by Dr. Kevin Barrett (view pdf), and The Trick of the Psychopath's Trade by Silvia Cattori (view pdf), it talks about why psychopaths have come to dominate all branches of government. It defines a psychopath as a person without a conscience. But corporations are, by definition, psychopaths - profitmaking machines without a soul. Like ninjas, they can wreak havoc, swipe the goods, and then vaporize at will. No matter what violence a company perpetrates to people or the environment, there's no culpability. Even if a case wins, it's appealed, and reappealed, until the company's changed hands and the players have switched places. The money has gone into off-shore tax havens, of which 72 now exist around the world. Not only do these avoid taxes, but no one knows the money's there. Countries are full of liabilities, otherwise known as people. But corporations are full of pockets, into which money goes, never to return. Lakshmi Mittal, the CEO, spent 60 million on his daughter's wedding – three times Liberia's vulture debt and more than twice their education and health budget combined.

Why are we holding countries liable for the climate debt instead of corporations? A country's GDP is seen as a reflection of its wealth, but it's really a measure of its population's vulnerability. It indicates the high cost of housing, of healthcare, of taxation, of monthly bills for necessities. baitandswitchnickelanddimed (13K) We're all temps in today's economy, fearful of losing the jobs we hate but can't live without. And now, as our schools close and we're counting how many paychecks we are away from being homeless, we're supposed to pay guilt-money for these drive-through junk food lives, spilling ketchup on our laps before the next interview, the next client call, the next time we have to sell ourselves as a perky prostitute for the business world?

I would like Vandana Shiva to read Barbara Ehrenreich's books Bait and Switch and Nickel and Dimed. Then she can explain to me how a person who isn't lazy and isn't greedy can make an ethical living in the US. If there's one thing that Barbara brings into sharp relief, it's the trap in which American workers are caught. Those saying we owe a climate debt cite the billions conjured out of thin air to save the banks. Let's be clear. The money that saved the banks didn't come out of thin air. It came from the houses that held the hard-earned savings of families. It came from the pension funds that vanished into 401K's. It came from bankrupting city budgets.

So here's my solution to climate change:

  1. Declare all national debts illegitimate. Has anyone of us ever voted for more debt? Was there a way to opt-out? To be born with debt is to be born an indentured servant, whose master keeps adding new loans. By refusing to pay their so-called debts, the global South can instead pay itself 200 billion a year starting immediately, instead of waiting for developed countries to pay them.
  2. Hold continental tribunals for crimes against the environment and humanity, putting both individuals and corporations on trial. Unless reparations are paid and time is served, revoke their concessions and visas. Agree among your countries not to harbor psychopaths or trade with countries that do. What is it that you need that you can't produce among yourselves?
  3. In the US, collect income tax at the county level before it goes to the state or the feds. Then, every year that the county reduces their emissions by 2%, allow them to keep 2% more of their own income taxes. The first result will be an honest assessment, because it's easier to knock off 2% if you're including the asparagus from Peru and the jeans from China. The second would be a shared incentive to reduce 20% by 2020, 40% by 2030, or even 80% by 2050. Now that's progress! The third effect would be a return to local sovereignty and a defunding of corporations and the governments that serve them. Now's that hope you can believe in!

For Third Paradigm, this has been Tereza Coraggio. Thanks to Skidmark Bob for sound production, and to Mike Scirocco for all things internet. Mike also has put a visitor map on the contact page. Over the last couple weeks, we've been visited by Israel, Portugal, Germany, Seychelles, and Baku, Azerbaijan. Thanks to Barbara Ehrenreich for an invigorating interview, that ranged from supply chain ethics to theodicy to American Unapparelled. You can hear the interview at the end of this show.

We go out with a song called The Price of Petrol by Seize the Day.
Listen to 'The Price of Petrol'

Barbara Ehrenreich Interview

In this fun and lively conversation, Tereza tells Barbara that Bright-Sided is a balm to her snarky soul.,8599,1821446,00.html Tereza proposes a support group called Kranky Misanthropes Anonymous, but Barbara has a better group started - the Negateers. They discuss magical thinking in religion and business, 'tit for tat' in cancer fundraising, how the office has been outsourced to the home, and the danger of shooting the messenger. Tereza relates two stories of being fired for not being a "can-do girl," and asks whether all middle-managers have now become "can-do girls" in this musical chairs jobless market.

Listen to the Interview

Show Information (includes MP3 download link)

Thank you for listening.